Skip to content
Part of the Law Professor Blogs Network

Prez Trump talking up death penalty for every murder in Washington DC

August 26, 2025

As reported in this CNN article, Prez Trump today was making a pitch for pursuit of the death penalty in response to ebery murder in Washington DC:

President Donald Trump said that his administration will seek the death penalty in all murder cases in Washington, DC, a move that could run into significant obstacles with city juries.

“Anybody murders something in the capital, capital punishment. Capital, capital punishment. If somebody kills somebody in the capital, Washington, DC, we’re going to be seeking the death penalty,” the president said during a meeting with Cabinet members Tuesday. The president did not immediately outline any specifics, but called capital punishment a “very strong preventative” measure….

Traditionally, the DC Superior Court handles the bulk of murder cases in the city, and it would be bound by the city code that does not authorize capital punishment. However, the US attorney’s office in DC, which prosecutes crimes in both the local and federal court in the city – unlike any other jurisdiction in the country – could bring federal charges in many capital-eligible cases and seek the death penalty….

Actually getting a death sentence, though, might not be so easy, as prosecutors would have to convince jurors to sign off. Historically, prosecutors have faced challenges in convincing special juries to impose capital punishment in DC, even if they vote unanimously to convict the defendants, multiple people in Washington’s legal community have told CNN in recent weeks.,,,

The federal court in the District of Columbia hasn’t held a death penalty trial since 2003, when Rodney L. Moore was convicted of 10 killings and Kevin L. Gray was convicted of 19 killings, according to multiple people familiar with the court and that case. In that case, the jurors said they couldn’t agree unanimously on death sentences for the two men rather than life imprisonment, court records show….

In recent months, the Justice Department has indicated in at least three cases in DC’s federal court that it may seek the death penalty, according to court records. One of those cases is against Elias Rodriguez, who is accused of shooting two Israeli embassy staff members leaving a Jewish community event in May. The Department of Justice is also actively considering seeking the death penalty in DC District Court for two Mexican nationals who were charged in 2008 in a gang case and recently brought to the US, and for two young men who were indicted for a 2023 carjacking, according to court records.

Unless the Justice Department was prepared to reassign a lot of additional prosecutors to the DC, it likely would prove extremely difficult as a practical matter for the feds to bring dozens and dozens of capital prosecutors in the Capitol.  It will be interesting to see if this tough talk is followed by any significant actions.