Skip to content
Part of the Law Professor Blogs Network

Justice Department now asserting in some cases that Prez Trump’s Jan 6 pardons covers gun and drug crimes

As reported in this new NPR article, headlined “Justice Department broadens Jan 6 pardons to cover gun, drug-related charges,” the Justice Department is now concurring with some defendants claims that Prez Trump’s Jan 6 pardons covers more than Jan 6 activity.  Here are some details with a focus on one case (and links from the original):

The Department of Justice has widened the scope of President Trump’s pardons for Jan. 6 riot defendants to include separate but related gun charges. The charges stemmed from FBI searches executed during the sprawling investigation into the Jan. 6, 2021 attack, which allegedly turned up evidence of other crimes not directly connected to the Capitol breach.

In legal filings this week, federal prosecutors asked judges to dismiss cases against two former Jan. 6 defendants, who had both faced federal gun charges.

This week’s legal filings represent a more expansive understanding of Trump’s Jan. 6 pardons than was initially clear. Trump’s order, which he issued on his first day in office, gave clemency for “offenses related to events that occurred at or near the United States Capitol” on Jan. 6.

Immediately after Trump’s pardons — which included defendants who violently assaulted police officers and those with long criminal records — the Department of Justice appeared to stand by the separate gun charges. That was then.

In the case against Elias Costianes of Maryland, federal prosecutors alleged he joined the mob that breached the U.S. Capitol on Jan. 6, and took videos of himself inside of the building. Costianes pleaded not guilty to the Jan. 6 charges, and his case was still pending when Trump took office and ordered the dismissal of all ongoing Capitol riot cases. But that was not Costianes’ only legal problem. When FBI agents first arrested Costianes and searched his residence on Feb. 12, 2021, they found four guns, along with evidence that Costianes used and sold cocaine and testosterone.

Costianes pleaded guilty to a charge of possession of a firearm or ammunition by an unlawful user of a controlled substance. He was sentenced to a year in prison, which he began serving earlier this month.

This week, the Department of Justice said in a court filing that it had concluded that Trump’s pardon order extended to Costianes’ drug and gun case, because it was sufficiently related to his Jan. 6 charges.  “He should be immediately released from custody in connection with this case because the President has pardoned him of the offenses in the indictment,” the government’s lawyers wrote….

In the legal filing in Costianes’ case, Department of Justice lawyers said, “Whether the pardon applies is a fact-intensive and case-specific inquiry.”

Meanwhile, on a somewhat related front, here are links to a couple of recent news pieces about some of the beneficiaries of Jan 6 pardons that caught my eye:

From The Hill, “Pardoned Jan. 6 defendants get hero’s welcome, star status at CPAC

From the New York Times, “Pardoned for Jan. 6, She Came Home to a New Reality

From NPR, “Pardoned Jan. 6 rioter from Washington state has a new passion — reforming the justice system