Skip to content
Part of the Law Professor Blogs Network

Rounding up reviews of SCOTUS oral arguments on religious liberty in death chamber

On Tuesday morning, the US Supreme Court heard oral argument in Ramirez v. Collier to consider whether a condemned prisoner can have his pastor physically touch him and audibly pray in the execution chamber while he is being executed.  I have not yet had a chance to listen to the oral argument (which is available here), but a quick scan of a number of press reports suggests the Justices were split on the matter.  Here is a partial round-up of blog and press comment on the argument:

From NPR, “Supreme Court conservatives are skeptical on spiritual advisers in death chamber

From SCOTUSblog, “Court debates inmate’s request for prayer and touch during execution, but a key justice remains silent

From Slate, “The Supreme Court’s Conservatives Finally Found a Religious Objection They Don’t Like

From USA Today, “Texas death row case: Supreme Court wrestles with religious freedom in the execution chamber.”